Bakir Oweida
Below is google translation of a piece for me that was published in my Arabic website.
Tuesday 29/01/2013
Evening, I could see the comments value honors owners allocate time and effort to write them, and then sent electronically to the comments section newspaper “Elaf” for publication, commenting on what included my article published yesterday morning (Monday, 28 this month) under the title: “resistance coup soldiers on the state .. and the desire of the West regional stability. ” I do not have words enough to meet the liberated each comment right. Right that the comments upscale than any article sang, adding a new dimension of opinion contained Palmqalh, or by information new, and possibly a historical reminder of the fact became forgotten archive memory. In this context, we can say that each comment valuable, useful to the readers of the article, as much as it enriches the author / Katebtha knowledge, expertise, and experience.
All thanks and appreciation for those who prefer talkback and pride, reprinted here in “Darbakir”, while retaining the link opinion page article in the “Elaph”, always thanked.
http://www.elaph.com/Web/opinion/2013/1/789145.html?entry=opinion
***
1. meanings stability
Nihad Ismail – London – GMT 12:19 2013 Monday January 28
Raises an article Mr. Bakir are issues that need to works of research and study where they can not be given the right to an article perhaps no more than 700 words. In any case difficult question Would the West really in the stability of the region?. The beginning of the word stability does not mean the same thing to all States. If we put Israel on the list of West Stability for her is the persistence of conflicts and divisions and problems to the Arab world works and to divert attention from its settlement and overwhelm the Palestinian Authority and the frustration of the Palestinian people. This may mean stability for Israel survival systems that protect the borders and Israel’s security, such as the Egyptian regime and former current Syrian regime, which is still struggling to survive. As Western countries any European Union and the United States yes want stable than the kind that ensures three main things: 1 – stability prevents export extremism and terrorism to its territory 2 – and stability does not threaten the security of Israel 3 – and stability to ensure the safety and continued oil and gas, trade and navigation. If the intent of question you are with revolutions and the consolidation of democracy tend to answer yes if guaranteed three things mentioned. Some believe that stability may mean survival dictatorships in their respective locations. But the Arab Spring revolutions have proved that Russia and China, you still keener on the survival of dictatorships in Libya, Syria and Sudan also that the West welcomes the change, but with caution.
2. desire to stability
Bodor Zaki Mohammed – GMT 15:50 2013 Monday January 28
Involve questions Mr. Bakir Oweida to pursue minutes of the reality of what happened and is happening in more than one Arab country and Islamic, after the tragedy of the hostages in Algeria, raised Elaph in a report news, question, and decided the case, the question is: in any trench fighting Qatar in Mali?, And the situation is: the so-called militants – softening of their crimes – live on money the country, this state of instability sponsored a rich country can not be convinced that its decision independent of the West, according to segregation referred to by Mr. Baker, West is not one, and that this small country but Tnevert with a side of their surroundings, they can not completely escape it. Money country contributed to the character path Syrian uprising and provoke the practices defined by the system lions, to fall in shafts sectarian, which is money that is going on in Iraq profusely and contributes to tensing the atmosphere or in the manufacture of tension from the ground up, as well as in Tunisia, Libya and Egypt (Incidentally there news is uncertain for a planned visit of Sheikh Qaradawi to the north of Iraq). Qatar as an example only, there are other Arab countries do not want stability only for its ruling, and ignores the fact that the chaos and terror diseases transient states and continents. To say that Alllepien lacked a sense of citizenship, or lack of sense of belonging to a country with constitutional legitimacy, also went Mr. Ghalbon, I find it is accurate, so that the state were not already established, and entities tribal were present in the composition, and the awareness of constitutional has not crystallized, as well as the majority of people are not politicized or enrolled in parties, and therefore not in a position to or awareness of a, take a position tightens, then that intent Gaddafi were not known from the outset addition, the tide of Nazareth expansionist had dominated much of the political formations Arab, and Abdel Nasser was the first to support Colonel Almenklb, and had contributed actively to undermine the First Republic Iraq just because it did not go in the line of Nazareth, in cooperation with the Americans. And here I remember painfully modern Iraqi woman wise, did not impair education little but taught herself بالمطالعة, and was passionate about politics, though she lived to the age now nearly eighty-fifth, said: I was astonished to talk people with minds of their love for Nasser and patriotism and Arabism, who The U.S. coup carefully measured, and the strangest of this form parties in his name after many years on the evil defeat inflicted on Arabs (here some apologize to those who still loyal to the memory of the late President, the talk was not me).
3. Islamic boarding political
Salah Abdel-Aziz – Switzerland – GMT 20:13 2013 Monday January 28
Essay – Bakir Oweida – essay discreet with insight and analysis close to reality … questionable – Dr. Mohammed Ahdash in place: Does the West really in the stability of the region? And diagnostic approach and individuals do not generalize, as the (common pronunciation not prevail) was a professor – Baker – right .. and I love that more point here is that in the interest of (Israel) that there is a rise of Islamic political states of the Arab Spring. .. And then Israel will find its argument to wage wars fiercer war (June – 1967) to look is in the position of defending oneself and that Fraúsa shiver of the Islamist takeover rule because if they were able, you may be issued combated and then remove it from the map … We question remains: Will the US-European alliance succeed in achieving Zionist temporary stability in the countries of the Arab Spring … And what are the mechanisms that take place behind the veil.
4. depth analysis
Ali Abu speech – GMT 2:00 2013 Althelaúa January 29
As long as we your analysis fascinating and I see in the revolutions of Arab States that it devolved to failure because the army ruled with the Muslim Brotherhood, for example in Tunisia, Egypt, Here now awaiting failure Brotherhood of due control himself because of chaos current either Libya it must first be imposed control and disarm the militias to be able to establish civil order not نفجع Lebanon or other Aganstan.
5. Noam Chomsky
D. Muhammad Ali, Ahdash – GMT 5:05 2013 Althelaúa January 29
I thank Professor Mr. Bakir Oweida essay deep and thank the good he thinks I have had the privilege to identify him good at that meeting, and I thank the participants with us at that meeting. I remember now writes and lectures Noam Chomsky many saying the American leader the West today are interested in having failed states and known as weak states belonging to the unwillingness security and flourishes where corruption, and that America is fighting a sense of national democracy and independence, and not a secret revolving door policy Fterdja revolutions where it came from series complex arrangements that overstretch people short of breath and memory, and experimented in Latin America and elsewhere, if at all is the face of success and failure defend, safely ĎăĘă.
6. revolution continues despite obstacles
Libyan – GMT 10:49 2013 Tuesday January 29,
There are three main themes together and share Libyan situation Taatqazv and adversely affect it at the moment! First axis Western interests and II ousted buried and the third new rulers associated Balotnin They couriers authority and postmen no homeland and found Dhalthm influence in external support to survive and support Cronies to disrupt the lives of people more فيبقون in power as possible to loot!! It will not be easy to control the ousted buried by mutual concessions of oppressed people by the remnants of the era of corruption on the other hand if you are willing to repent!! This requires strong leadership sincere elected by the overwhelming majority and this character is not much hope in their appearance now because obliterate the Libyan identity over forty years! There is a clear exclusion of honest and young people who have revolution and faced bullets Gaddafi bare بصدورهم and those intellectuals left their work and participated in the struggle and not actual articles They count on them to rid Libya who are trying to catch them again! The question of who is keen on the stability of the country and the driven them to the lights for people to recognize them and Akhtarōhm?? The opposite is happening have been marginalized and excluded do not even contemplate them one!! No lens focuses only on the two main factions known share and Atkhasman their interests and not the interests of the country and most of them work sincerely with Gaddafi and his son, it is who is behind the appointment of officials and insist on keeping them in office despite the objections of the people they sometimes even armed?? !! Ousted assassin keen to mess with conspiracy and rumors they give between the folds of the people suffered underdevelopment Faihdthon confusion .. and found their destination, it is the avenging hand of their leader, as well as guarantee the continued looting which Aatadoh! This usually looting commissions?? Where do these come from commissions only from investments?? Early Time to call the federal leaders and suspects?? Despite the refusal of the majority!! The same thing in the south of Libya and seize its borders intervention traveled from countries border that harbor remnants of the regime and who are working to destabilize security in the south and neglecting the situation in the south of the existing and leaving them easy targets for Maamra T. Saadi and his mercenaries until noon separatists in the south as well?? Why do not deliver Saadi is wanted criminal?? But I have asked France from Niger Tstusi to do good when he escaped them instead of claim Btzlmah?? There is an important question of who put huge amounts of arms and ammunition to the Libyan desert sands immediately after liberation time when the country was under international control and could have been a full blown before the end of the embargo?? Accelerate the formulation of the Constitution is the decisiveness that will remove the doubts about the question of stability! There is a feeling a clear agenda to disable it and argue behind this disruption not to activate the law and the establishment of the army which is the agenda as well as both linked to the other!! At a time where the conference meet to discuss side issues to prove the existence of not only!! Perhaps because King Idris constitution-making God’s mercy and had intended to make constitutional reforms and united the country after it was trilateral regions then appeared oil became desirable Votih and a smattering Gaddafi?!! History tells us that when demonstrators attacked the palace – and who knew that he deceived them too late – they were chanting the devil nor Idriss King lifted his hands to the sky asking God to be invited!! Perhaps the crux of the matter, who answers some questions writer … Thanks to the author comments brotherhood!
7. brother Nihad Ismail
Libyan – GMT 11:25 2013 Tuesday January 29,
If dreams are true peoples revolutions, this is contrary to Western interests! Point on the line!! Support for dictators biggest proof of that!! So let not achieve the hopes and goals of revolutions part of a scheme instability so that you do for these states list! And end up to the heads of the same new Tina gowns and its not in her hand! ! The Western intervention in Libya – despite coming a formal request from the people from within the interest of participating States – was to fears of leakage arms Libyan and illegal immigration and fears of piracy average – Vat a people rebellious in eliminating Gaddafi and won the lion’s share in the benefits of oil and investments they smote sparrows many with one stone! Now required vigilance and statesmanship of individuals and civic organizations emerging to enlighten people to miss out on everyone play Bmusaúrha more than it was!! These interests also are not the same in the Syrian situation, despite the similarity of tyrants and the severity of the need for this non-military intervention if more than the Libyan situation! But the possibility of extremism and terrorism does not seem to affect them as much as they fear the conflict could spill over and swells hurting the interests of the greatest!
8. Libyan Sister comments 7
Nihad Ismail – London – GMT 13:28 2013 Althelaúa 29 January
Thank Sister Libyan and agreed with our sister said Western countries put their own interests above all other considerations. And Western support for the Arab Spring revolutions associated interests, as I said in my comment above. Western reluctance to provide sufficient support for the Syrian opposition regards mainly to Israel’s security. From my readings and I can Mtabati say that the West does not want a new system anonymously may create trouble and problems for Israel in the Golan Heights and the northern front. In general, despite the West’s desire to protect its interests, but the fall of tyrants would be in the interest of the peoples of the region in the long run.
9. When are we going to blame the West
Structure Azmi – GMT 15:52 2013 Althelaúa 29 January
Seems to be the situation of the Arab addiction to blame others for their misfortunes continuous and pervasive even in the ranks of the class claims of science and knowledge.
10. visit Qaradawi is incorrect
Dadیar – GMT 23:44 2013 Tuesday January 29,
First it is the province of Kurdistan and in accordance with the Constitution and not the Iraqi northern Iraq II: Government Province categorically denied an invitation-Qaradawi to the Kurdistan region, but was a piece by the Muslim Brotherhood did not succeed, I hope that you be careful.
bakiroweida 